Both products sit in Sheba's pouch wet food range and both use 85g pouches. The main difference is pack format: Selection comes as a 12-pouch box, Nature's Collection as a 4-pouch pack.

Both are commonly sold as multi-recipe mixes, but the exact combination changes with retailer and promotion. Check the recipe labels on the pack rather than inferring from the range name.

For use, the 12-pouch box suits multi-cat homes or households that already know their cat accepts the food, cutting down on restocking. The 4-pouch pack suits a first trial to see how a cat responds to the recipes and texture.

Neither can be judged complete or complementary from the range name alone. Check whether the specific recipe is labelled complete food; only a complete-and-balanced recipe is suitable as a long-term sole diet.

Storage is the same for both: keep unopened packs cool and out of direct light, refrigerate after opening, and finish within 24 hours.

Image credit: Sheba Selection 12×85g and Nature's Collection 4×85g photographed on a supermarket shelf, CC0 1.0, by Abraham, via Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:20250828_Sheba_Auchan_Miko%C5%82%C3%B3w_01.jpg, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:20250828_Sheba_Auchan_Miko%C5%82%C3%B3w_03.jpg).